Real Estate Market Statistics & AnalysisDeutsch

Methodology

A Link compares one real estate KPI (key figure) with one economic indicator (a figure from the wider economy) over a period we state. It shows whether the two moved together. It does not show that one causes the other, and it is not a forecast.

Each Link has three parts:

Frequency. A Link uses the real estate KPI’s own rhythm, quarterly or yearly. We average monthly and quarterly economic indicators over each quarter or calendar year. We leave out any quarter or year with missing data.

Minimum overlap. A comparison over too few periods can mislead. Each shift needs at least 40 periods for quarterly real estate KPIs and 10 for yearly real estate KPIs. Below that, we leave the shift blank. We show a Link only if the comparison with no shift reaches that minimum and at least three shifts in all do. Otherwise the panel says “Link not shown”. It gives n with no shift, and it says whether there were too few periods or one series did not change. For yearly Links with fewer than 20 periods, we add a note that the pattern may be chance.

Choosing a shift on the Links page. Above the table, you can pick one shift. It applies to every box in the table. You can choose:

Each box shows the same number as the matching bar on the real estate KPI page. For a quarterly real estate KPI, N-1 and N-2 mean 4 and 8 quarters earlier. If a box has too few periods at the chosen shift, it says “Not shown”. The table opens on “Pre-set”. We explain it in the next paragraph. The page address changes with your choice, so you can copy it to share your view.

Initial yield, office and retail combined, 7 major citiesSame yearEconomic indicator 1 year earlier (N-1)Economic indicator 2 years earlier (N-2)
10-year Bund yield0.11n = 30within chance range0.4n = 30pre-set shift: N-10.43n = 30
Euribor 3 months-0.13n = 30within chance range0.35n = 30within chance rangepre-set shift: N-10.32n = 29within chance range
Loan rate, non-financial corporations, rate fixed for over 5 years0.22n = 22within chance range0.6n = 21pre-set shift: N-10.41n = 20within chance range
Example: three rows of the Links table, one for each interest rate, at each of the three shifts. An olive green box is outside the chance range: the two tended to rise and fall together, and the deeper the green, the larger the number. A grey box is inside the chance range. The pre-set shift is marked.

Colours of the boxes. Olive green means the two tended to rise and fall together. Violet means one tended to rise when the other fell. The deeper the colour, the larger the number. A grey box is inside the chance range, so its number may be random. We explain the range further down.

A pre-set shift for appraisal-based real estate KPIs. Initial yield and the commercial property price index rest mostly on appraisals (valuations by experts). Appraisals follow interest rates with a delay. We compare these two real estate KPIs with the 10-year Bund yield (the interest rate on 10-year German government bonds), Euribor 3 months and the loan rate. For these pairs, we chose one year earlier (N-1) in advance. We chose it for economic reasons, not from the results. On “Pre-set”, these boxes are marked “pre-set shift: N-1”. Pick another shift and every box shows that shift, without the mark. On the Link panels, the +1 bar has the same label, separate from the “strongest” mark. If you switch between shifts and keep the one that looks strongest, you overstate the link. This is the same problem as with the “strongest” mark.

-1-0.500.51Rank correlation-3-2-10+1+2+3Shift in years (positive: economic indicator moved earlier, negative: later)-3: 0.1-2: 0.06-1: 0.140: 0.11+1: 0.4+2: 0.43+3: 0.11pre-set shift-1-0.500.51Rank correlation-3-2-10+1+2+3Shift in years (positive: economic indicator moved earlier, negative: later)-3: 0.1-2: 0.06-1: 0.140: 0.11+1: 0.4+2: 0.43+3: 0.11pre-set shift
Example: the dashed outline marks the pre-set shift, N-1 (+1 in the bar chart). We chose it in advance.

Grey boxes and the band on the bars. A correlation based on few data points can be random. The fewer the data points, the more likely it is that a strong-looking number is just luck. So we draw a band: the range of numbers that luck alone often gives. If a box’s number is inside the band, the box is grey. This means the number may be random. You can still read it. The band depends on n, the number of data points (periods compared) in that box at the chosen shift. The smaller n is, the wider the band. We work it out as ±2/√(n−1). Each Link panel draws the same band as a light strip on its bars. Quarterly real estate KPIs need one more step. Each change is compared with the same quarter a year earlier, so neighbouring quarters overlap. We count n ÷ 4 (rounded down) data points instead. The panel shows both numbers.

-1-0.500.51Rank correlation-3-2-10+1+2+3Shift in years (positive: economic indicator moved earlier, negative: later)-3: 0.1-2: 0.06-1: 0.140: 0.11+1: 0.4+2: 0.43+3: 0.11-1-0.500.51Rank correlation-3-2-10+1+2+3Shift in years (positive: economic indicator moved earlier, negative: later)-3: 0.1-2: 0.06-1: 0.140: 0.11+1: 0.4+2: 0.43+3: 0.11
Example: the light grey strip is the chance range at each shift. A bar that stays inside the strip may be random.

Many boxes at once. The Links page shows many comparisons together. So a few boxes will look strong by chance alone, just as several shifts tried on one Link will give a good-looking one. Be careful with a single strong box, especially when n is small.

Nominal and real. Nominal means not adjusted for inflation. Real means adjusted for inflation. Rents and transaction volume are in nominal euros. So are the consumer price index and construction prices. Their Links to those two economic indicators therefore partly reflect the same inflation. Real GDP (gross domestic product, the value of all goods and services produced) is adjusted for inflation. So a Link between a nominal real estate KPI and real GDP compares nominal with real. The rent and transaction volume rows on the Links page carry a note about this. So do their Link panels for these three economic indicators. We do not adjust any figure for inflation in a Link.

Rows and areas. The rows on the Links page cover different Segments (property types) and areas. Each row starts with a tag that names its own: commercial overall or office, Germany or the 7 major cities, and for initial yield office and retail combined. Every economic indicator is national. So reading down a column compares unlike things. On a City class or Land view, the Link compares the national economic indicator with the real estate KPI for that area.

The eight economic indicators

  1. 10-year Bund yield (Deutsche Bundesbank), monthly.
  2. Euribor 3 months, monthly average (European Central Bank). It is the rate at which banks lend to each other for 3 months. We use it as a stand-in for the ECB policy rate (the ECB’s main interest rate).
  3. Interest rate on new loans to non-financial corporations (companies outside the financial sector) of over EUR 1 million, with the rate fixed for over 5 years (Deutsche Bundesbank), monthly. Commercial property is mostly financed with long fixed rates. So we use loans with a long fixed rate, not the floating rate.
  4. Consumer price index (Destatis), monthly. It follows the prices of a basket of goods that households buy.
  5. Real GDP (Deutsche Bundesbank), quarterly.
  6. Registered unemployment rate (Deutsche Bundesbank), monthly.
  7. Construction price index (Destatis), quarterly. We use office buildings for office views and for the construction of office buildings. We use industrial and commercial buildings for all other views.
  8. OECD business confidence (OECD), monthly. We use retail for retail views and construction for all other views. These series are not seasonally adjusted, so regular swings within the year stay in. They are percentage balances, so their changes are differences in percentage points.

Insights

An Insight draws several series on one chart over a period we state. It comes with a fixed one-line reading. Like a Link, it only describes what the lines show. It does not show a cause, and it is not a forecast. (One Insight compares with an earlier year that we fixed in advance. See Shift below.)

Which direction counts as better, for each Insight:

Insight Better when the value is Why
Spread of initial yield over the 10-year Bund yield, by City class higher more income per unit of price than a government bond pays
Spread of initial yield over the corporate loan rate higher more income per unit of price than the corporate loan rate costs
Ratio of office prices to office rents neither The number is a price-to-rent multiple, shown as an index (2015 = 100). When it is high, a buyer pays more per unit of rent and an owner holds more value. So it depends on whose side you take.
Real growth of office rents higher rents growing faster than prices generally
Spread of office rent growth over construction price growth higher rents growing faster than the cost of building
Spread of real office rent growth over real GDP growth higher Real rents grow faster than the real economy. This is a close call: it also means a rising cost burden for occupiers. It is an editorial judgement.
Ratio of office completions to permits two years earlier neither Fewer completions per permit mean less new supply for owners but fewer projects for developers. It depends on whose side you take.
Real growth of construction prices lower Building and refurbishing costs that rise faster than prices generally make new investment more expensive. This is an editorial judgement.
Spread of office vacancy in the 7 major cities over the 127 towns lower A positive gap means the 7 major cities are emptier than the 127 towns, which is worse. A negative gap is better.

Insight figures are our own calculation. This covers gaps, ratios, averages and series set to 100 in the base year. We mark them as such in the source lines.

How to read these figures